Skip to content
SurenoGet Sureno Browser
← Sureno News

Up 50.8%: KiwiSaver hardship withdrawals spiking; are there better ways to deal with debt?

Hardship withdrawals rise sharply

More New Zealanders are seeking access to KiwiSaver funds because of financial hardship. Withdrawals totalled NZ$443.6 million in the year to March 31, 2025, compared with $264.3 million in the previous year, a 50.8% increase.

IRD figures to September 2026 show first-home withdrawals still exceed hardship withdrawals in value. However, hardship applications now outnumber applications to withdraw money for a first home. The article describes current hardship withdrawals as roughly three times pre-COVID levels and links the rise to expanding poverty.

Financial mentors said hardship applications represented one in eight of their clients. The people consulted for the research viewed the applications as a sign of the financial stress facing New Zealanders.

Support before applying

FinCap asked Victoria University of Wellington to examine ways people facing hardship could keep funds in KiwiSaver. Researchers spoke with financial mentors, Debtfix, KiwiSaver providers and the Retirement Commission.

The report proposes offering financial mentoring to anyone applying for a hardship withdrawal, so they can consider alternatives before taking money out. Mentors can help people with unmanageable debt negotiate with creditors, seek government assistance or consider insolvency procedures.

Another proposal is a central clearing house for hardship applications and support. Mentors, debt management organisations and other services could assess people’s circumstances before a formal application is made.

Different processes for providers

The research found that KiwiSaver providers vary considerably in their application forms, processes and communication. That can force applicants and their mentors to adapt each application, making the process difficult and time-consuming.

One mentor described clients in prison seeking around $70 a week for 13 weeks to cover extra food, toiletries and similar needs. Some applications were approved and others were not, the mentor said.

The report recommends that agencies including the Retirement Commission and IRD work with providers to collect more information and standardise hardship processes. It also says the growing workload is receiving little recognition in an already underfunded financial mentoring sector. FinCap is advocating sustainable funding and organising a petition to government.

Options for emergency savings

The report recommends investigating and potentially trialling “sidecar” savings accounts linked to KiwiSaver. These accounts could help members build emergency funds they can access during hardship without drawing on the rest of their KiwiSaver balance.

The article notes that a National-led coalition government is likely to make KiwiSaver contributions compulsory for employers and employees. Labour has also promised compulsory employer contributions, and both major parties intend to raise contribution rates.

The Opportunity Party’s “KiwiSaver 2.0” proposal, part of a wider tax reset, would create a compulsory scheme with no hardship withdrawals. The research argues that any tougher savings model should balance long-term retirement interests with access to funds during present hardship.

Key points

  • Hardship withdrawals reached NZ$443.6 million in the year to March 31, 2025, a 50.8% annual increase.
  • Hardship applications now exceed first-home applications, though first-home withdrawals remain larger in total.
  • The report proposes financial mentoring, a central support clearing house and trials of linked emergency savings accounts.
  • Researchers recommend standardising provider processes and examining the workload facing financial mentors.
Read the original on The Conversation ↗

More news

Loading stories…