Sotheby’s Risk-Taking Left a $180 Million van Gogh in the Lurch

A disputed auction centerpiece
At a Friday dinner hosted by chief executive Charles Stewart, Sotheby’s welcomed wealthy guests and heard a speech about more than $1 billion in artworks scheduled for sale that week. Stewart did not mention that the week’s leading lot was already disputed.
The painting, “Châtaigniers en Fleurs (Blossoming Chestnut Trees),” is a landscape by van Gogh from 1890, valued at about $180 million. It is due to go under the hammer Wednesday.
Heirs seek withdrawal
Earlier Friday, Jewish heirs of a collector who once owned the work asked Sotheby’s to remove it from the auction. They assert that the painting was sold under duress in 1936 because of Nazi-era persecution.
Provenance draws scrutiny
Industry experts said questions about the van Gogh’s provenance had circulated before the planned sale. A public dispute could deter bidders concerned about how the painting reached the auction room. Philip Hoffman, an art adviser and former auction-world executive, described the situation as a problem for the auction house, the owners and prospective buyers.
Key points
- The van Gogh landscape is estimated to be worth around $180 million.
- Jewish heirs say the painting was sold under duress in 1936 amid Nazi-era persecution.
- Sotheby’s and the heirs are expected to meet Monday in Manhattan.
- Experts say the dispute could make potential buyers wary.

