Prime Ribeye Cap’s Marbling Shines Among 3 Costco Steaks Worth Buying in 2026, Mashed Finds
Three cuts to consider
The recommended steaks are all part of Costco’s Kirkland Signature line. The ribeye and New York strip are USDA Choice, while the boneless ribeye cap is USDA Prime.
Choice beef generally has less marbling than Prime, but can still offer tenderness and flavor at a lower price. Costco also sells beef from brands including Rastelli’s and Kansas City Steak Co.
Ribeye earns shopper praise
The Kirkland Signature USDA Choice Beef Ribeye Steak draws favorable comments from shoppers, who describe its quality as strong compared with cuts from other grocery retailers. Another commenter said the steak looked unusually good for Choice grade.
Ribeyes are popular restaurant steaks in the United States, according to the 2025 Cargill Future of Beef report. Buyers seeking a lower price may save $1 to $2 per pound by cutting steaks from larger portions, the Ohio Beef Council says.
New York strip offers value
In a ranking of grocery store New York strip steaks, the Kirkland Signature USDA Choice New York Steak placed second. A Reddit shopper shared a photo and questioned whether the heavily marbled steaks were really Choice grade.
At the time described in the article, the steaks cost $18.15 per pound. Some shoppers also point to buying a whole loin and trimming it themselves; one called a price of $9.99 per pound a good deal.
Prime ribeye cap stands out
The ribeye cap wraps around the ribeye’s central eye and is known for its marbling and flavor. The cut comes from the rib section, between the shoulder and the loin, and is less commonly found in grocery stores.
Steak enthusiasts have called Costco’s Prime boneless ribeye cap a top choice. The article notes that high heat is a useful approach when cooking it.
Key points
- Costco’s three recommended Kirkland Signature steaks are ribeye, New York strip and boneless ribeye cap.
- The ribeye and New York strip are Choice grade; the ribeye cap is Prime.
- At the time described, the Choice New York strip cost $18.15 per pound.
- Cutting steaks from larger beef portions may save $1 to $2 per pound, according to the Ohio Beef Council.