Tracker Needs a Major Change if It Wants to Remain Among CBS’ Biggest Shows

Colter Remains the Center

Tracker has returned to its familiar format: Colter Shaw, played by Justin Hartley, takes on new reward-seeking cases. His survivalist approach and life in an Airstream remain central to the series.

The show’s clear focus on Colter helps explain its appeal, but it also creates a challenge. The article argues that the rest of the main cast can feel adrift when they are not working alongside him.

The Office Move Takes Time

Season 4 delayed the move of Reenie Greene, Randy Davis and Mel Day to a Denver office. Instead, the characters spent several episodes in an office-hunt plot, which concluded in the fourth episode, “Purification.” Randy remains an important part of Colter’s operation, providing technical help that supports the work in the field. The show has also brought Randy and Reenie’s lives together, consolidating parts of the team’s role.

Reenie and Mel Need More

Reenie and Mel, played by Cassady McClincy Zhang, are currently involved in a murder-mystery plot that the article describes as lacking momentum. “Purification” offered a small step forward by having Mel recognize a medic, though the supplied account ends before explaining what followed.

The Wider Cast Has Potential

The article also points to Randy’s predecessor, Bobby Exley, as an example of a useful technical character. Eric Graise played Bobby from the pilot, and the piece praises his deadpan style and the behind-the-scenes work the role brings to a procedural.

Russell, Colter’s brother, is another recurring presence. Played by Jensen Ackles, the ex-military character remains difficult to classify as either help or trouble, a tension that has helped keep his return appearances interesting.