Cardinals, Twins Could Give Crawford a Better Deal Than Mariners Can

Two possible landing spots

The Athletic’s forecast gives Crawford a two-year, $20 million deal with St. Louis or Minnesota. The author considers that amount reasonable for a veteran whose role in Seattle has changed.

St. Louis could use a regular third baseman who can also cover shortstop and contribute steady at-bats. Crawford would not need to take on a large share of the team’s responsibilities, and his experience could help the roster.

Minnesota offers flexibility

The Twins could value Crawford’s ability to move around the infield. He could play third base, fill in at shortstop, and take second base when needed. Neither club would be counting on him for 20 or more home runs or a return to Gold Glove form. His value would be in providing dependable options and making it easier to set the lineup.

Seattle faces a transition

Crawford yielded shortstop after Colt Emerson arrived and moved to third base. Seattle now has young infielders seeking playing time, while Emerson is viewed as the shortstop of the future.

Crawford’s 0.9 bWAR season and reduced range at shortstop do not make him indispensable. Still, his exit would mean losing the security he offered, not just replacing his individual production.

The lineup remains a concern

Seattle scored 664 runs in 2026, the third-lowest total in baseball. The team may have reason to move on from Crawford, but it cannot assume its internal depth has already solved the problem.

The Mariners need a stronger lineup and must avoid placing too much pressure on young infielders too soon. If Crawford signs elsewhere and becomes a reliable answer for another club, Seattle’s confidence in its transition will face scrutiny.