Kardashian’s Infamous Legal Drama Returns Despite Horrendous 6% Score

A second season arrives

All’s Fair, co-created by Ryan Murphy, returns with three new episodes on Wednesday, November 4. The series stars Kardashian and follows legal disputes and conflicts among attorneys. The return comes despite the first season’s very low critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes. No reviews for the new season had appeared there at the time of writing, so its reception remains unknown.

Viewers showed up anyway

Season 1 debuted on November 4, 2025, with three episodes. It attracted 3.2 million views in its first three days and became Hulu’s biggest original series debut in three years at that time.

The series also rose to the top of Hulu and Disney+’s global viewership chart and generated millions of social media impressions and views. Its audience score on Rotten Tomatoes was 65%, far above its 6% critics’ score.

Criticism and streaming success

Reviews were sharply negative. The Atlantic described the episodes as “Instagram Reels at episode length,” while The Hollywood Reporter criticized Kardashian’s performance and the writing. Despite that response, the show found a large audience. Season 2 will test whether it can keep viewers now that the initial online excitement has eased.

Rivalries continue in season two

The new season carries on the conflict between Kardashian’s attorney, Allura Grant, and rival Carrington Lane, played by Sarah Paulson. Tensions also remain among Grant’s law-firm partners Liberty Ronson, played by Naomi Watts, and Emerald Greene, played by Niecy Nash-Betts.

The season could address criticism of the first, though the article says it is unclear whether the creative team has changed its approach. The series will also seek to reclaim the top worldwide position on Hulu and Disney+.