Was treated sewage to blame at Britain’s worst bathing site? Tests raise questions

A bathing site with warnings
An official sign at French Weir Park advises people not to swim. The site became an official bathing site in 2024, bringing Environment Agency testing from May to September.
Despite health warnings and high faecal bacteria levels, swimmers Jenny Hillier and Jo Macdonald have continued to visit. Macdonald says they sometimes avoid swimming because of the water’s appearance or smell, and take precautions when they do enter.
Tests show frequent failures
The article says official advice last year was against swimming at 12 of England’s 14 inland river bathing sites. Seas may disperse and dilute faecal bacteria more effectively than rivers or lakes.
Possible sources remain unclear
Wessex Water said bacteria at French Weir Park could come from wildlife, agriculture, private septic tanks or its sewerage works. Testing suggests bacteria have been entering the River Tone consistently, but the source is not established.
Dr Rob Morley of Index Microbiology examined samples near the wastewater treatment works. One sample showed 199 CFU of E. coli above the works and 7,701 CFU below it, more than eight times the regulator’s limit.
Limits and further testing
Morley said the results showed the possible effect of treated effluent on the river, while expecting levels to fall farther downstream through dilution. The article also reports that current laws and regulations do not set a limit for bacteria in treated effluent discharged by water companies.
The BBC’s analysis found many different types of E. coli in samples from the bathing site, making the source difficult to identify. Wessex Water said its Bradford on Tone treatment works was operating normally and meeting all Environment Agency permit conditions; further testing is needed for firm conclusions.
Key points
- French Weir Park failed 13 of 19 tests this summer, a 68% failure rate.
- The BBC’s 2026 analysis found the site had the highest failure rate among bathing sites.
- E. coli levels were much higher below than above the wastewater treatment works.
- The bacteria’s source at the bathing site remains uncertain.

