UK politics: Shabana Mahmood pledges to tackle corrosive and growing perception of two-tier policing

Addressing concerns about fairness
Mahmood is due to speak to the National Police Chiefs’ Council about concerns that police treat different groups differently. She will say that most officers serve impartially and without favour, while acknowledging that some cases have harmed confidence in policing.
Mahmood will also call it “shameful” that the proportion of black officers has barely changed in the 33 years since the murder of Stephen Lawrence. She is expected to caution that some equality initiatives, including a former police anti-racism commitment, risk weakening confidence in impartial policing.
New guidance for police
A new impartiality standard is being developed for police forces. It is intended to bring key principles together and help officers handle cases consistently, whatever a person’s race, faith or other characteristics.
The standard also aims to reassure the public that they will be treated fairly and give police greater confidence in their decisions. Mahmood will warn against what she calls misguided efforts to correct inequality if they lead to different treatment.
Limits on political engagement
Mahmood will urge officers to avoid engaging with activist groups, arguing that such groups may promote agendas without representing whole communities. She says community engagement should instead involve listening to residents and discussing local concerns. Her message to police leaders is to leave political decisions to politicians and policing to officers.
Key points
- Mahmood will address the National Police Chiefs’ Council on concerns about two-tier policing.
- A More in Common poll found 33% believe police favour ethnic minority people over white people.
- A new impartiality standard is being developed to guide police treatment of the public.
- Mahmood will warn that equality efforts must not lead to differential treatment.

