Seven UC researchers retain grants as Supreme Court keeps injunction against DEI grant defunding in place

Supreme Court declines appeal
The Supreme Court announced Monday that it would not hear the government’s appeal of a lower court ruling protecting grants for seven University of California researchers. The justices offered no explanation, and none filed a dissent.
The case had once involved a larger group of researchers and grants from many federal agencies. After a Supreme Court ruling directed most grant termination cases to another court, this case was narrowed to seven researchers and grants involving the Environmental Protection Agency, the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities.
How the grants were canceled
The grants were terminated after agencies concluded they conflicted with a Trump executive order blocking the use of DEI. The government had not defined DEI, and targeted grants were often identified through keyword searches.
The researchers argued that canceling their grants amounted to viewpoint discrimination barred by the First Amendment. A District Court agreed and issued a preliminary injunction requiring the grants to be restored.
Appeals court cites free speech
A Court of Appeals panel upheld the injunction. It said the government could eliminate grant programs it no longer considered appropriate, but could not cancel individual awards within existing programs based on the perceived views of their recipients.
The panel cited Supreme Court precedent on religious viewpoint discrimination. It reasoned that DEI expresses the view that excluding historically disadvantaged groups is undesirable, and that the cancellations targeted speakers’ perceived viewpoints.
Potential wider legal impact
The decision directly protects only seven researchers, but the lower court’s First Amendment reasoning could have broader implications. The Supreme Court may have other opportunities to consider the dispute if it continues. The court’s decision not to intervene may be read by other courts as a sign that the government’s anti-DEI efforts face legal uncertainty.
Key points
- The Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal involving grants for seven University of California researchers.
- Lower courts found that canceling individual grants based on perceived viewpoints violated the First Amendment.
- The grants involved the Environmental Protection Agency, National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities.
- The Supreme Court gave no explanation for declining the appeal, and no justice dissented.

