Skip to content
SurenoGet Sureno Browser
← Sureno News

With Rotation Depth, Should Pirates Join Dustin May Free Agent Race?

May draws widespread interest

May pitched for the Los Angeles Dodgers and Boston Red Sox in 2025, then the St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers in 2026. He won the World Series with Milwaukee, but posted a 14-20 record, 4.82 ERA and 1.37 WHIP across 54 starts and 278 innings over the past two seasons.

Recent performance raises concerns

May missed most of the four seasons before becoming a full-time starter over the past two. In 2026, opponents hit the ball hard against him: his hard-hit rate was 44.3%, and his average exit velocity allowed was 90.0 mph.

His four-seam fastball, cutter and sinker each contributed to a combined +5 run value, according to Statcast. His sweeper, curveball and changeup combined for a -12 run value. In the postseason, he recorded a 5.73 ERA over five games, including two starts, with 11 hits allowed in 11 innings and a .262 batting average against.

Pirates have a rotation gap

Pittsburgh’s projected rotation is entirely right-handed: Paul Skenes, Braxton Ashcraft, Jared Jones, Mitch Keller and Bubba Chandler. The article says each performed well in 2026, while noting that opponents could benefit from the lack of left-handed pitching.

The Pirates have reportedly been looking for a left-handed pitcher. The team has previously signed left-handed free agents Andrew Heaney in 2025, Martín Pérez in 2024, Rich Hill in 2023, José Quintana in 2022 and Tyler Anderson in 2021.

Cost and alternatives matter

May’s demand could require Pittsburgh to make a sizable offer, and the Pirates do not need to add a starter simply to add one. The article argues that his recent performance makes him a poor answer for the team in 2027.

Potential left-handed options named include veterans Robbie Ray, Trevor Rogers and Foster Griffin. Pittsburgh must decide how much to spend and whether free agency or a trade would be the better route.

Key points

  • Eight teams are reportedly interested in Dustin May, according to Jim Bowden of The Athletic.
  • May recorded a 4.82 ERA across 54 starts over the past two seasons.
  • Pittsburgh’s listed rotation options are all right-handed.
  • The Pirates are weighing left-handed pitching options through free agency or a trade.
Read the original on Pittsburgh Pirates On SI ↗

More news

Loading stories…