Clarence Thomas questions sensitive-place bans as Supreme Court turns away challenge to Maryland restrictions on guns in parks and schools

Maryland’s restrictions challenged
Maryland enacted new limits in 2023 after the Supreme Court recognized a right to carry guns outside the home. The rules bar firearms at daycare and medical facilities, government buildings and other places where people gather for entertainment, education or social activities.
Two groups of plaintiffs sued on the day the restrictions were signed, challenging rules covering 10 categories of places. The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld all the challenged restrictions under the Supreme Court’s historical-tradition test.
Appeal asks justices to intervene
Maryland residents and gun rights groups asked the Supreme Court to take up their case. They said intervention could help lower courts define the historical boundaries of public gun rights as more states adopt limits tied to specific locations.
Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown argued the laws are constitutional because they fit a historical tradition of restricting firearms in certain settings. He cited locations that are “confined and crowded,” according to Brown.
Thomas signals continuing doubts
Justice Clarence Thomas supported declining the case but expressed skepticism about sensitive-place restrictions. He urged the court to consider state authority over such bans in a more narrowly focused case.
The court last year struck down a Hawaii law requiring concealed-carry permit holders to obtain permission before bringing guns onto private property open to the public. In 2024, it upheld a federal law barring people subject to domestic violence restraining orders from possessing guns. In its most recent term, the justices unanimously ruled that the Second Amendment does not permit prosecuting someone who uses marijuana occasionally.
Key points
- The Supreme Court declined to review Maryland’s restrictions on guns in sensitive places.
- Justice Clarence Thomas questioned the constitutionality of such restrictions while agreeing not to hear the case.
- The 4th Circuit upheld all challenged Maryland restrictions under the court’s historical-tradition test.
- The dispute involves 10 categories of locations and limits enacted in 2023.

