DC's Clayface officially overtaking Supergirl after being removed from 1,200 theaters

A difficult period for DC
DC Studios, a Warner Bros. subsidiary, has gone through a major leadership change, with co-CEOs James Gunn and Peter Safran removed. The studio’s plans are unsettled, although Gunn has a Superman movie scheduled for 2027.
Gunn and Safran had pledged to make films that did not depend on expanding shared universes and would be approved only when their scripts met the mark. Superman, the first film under their leadership, received mostly positive reviews, but the studio’s fortunes later worsened.
Supergirl faces a new rival
Supergirl, the DC Universe’s second big-screen release, performed poorly and is described as one of 2026’s biggest flops. Clayface, the franchise’s latest feature, is set to overtake it.
The article says the choice to make a standalone anti-hero film the franchise’s third installment may have contributed to Gunn and Safran’s departure. It also says the studio wants its most popular characters to lead toward a Justice League film.
Clayface earns stronger reviews
Directed by James Watkins, Clayface is a body horror film with a 78% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, where it is rated “Certified Fresh.” The site’s consensus describes it as a distinctive DCU entry that becomes a satisfying revenge thriller. Clayface also has a 94% audience score on the site, marked “Verified Hot.” Supergirl, by contrast, received mixed reviews from critics earlier in the year.
Key points
- Clayface is set to overtake Supergirl after being removed from 1,200 theaters.
- Supergirl performed poorly and is described as one of 2026’s biggest flops.
- Clayface has a 78% critics’ score and a 94% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes.
- DC Studios’ future plans are uncertain following the removal of James Gunn and Peter Safran.

