A Gun Raises Questions as Batman Finally Confronts Batwoman About Her Most Sacred Rule After She Breaks It

A conflict between cousins
Kate Kane has carried the Batwoman name in comics for 20 years. Bruce Wayne is her maternal cousin, and she became a vigilante before learning he was Batman. When he later disclosed his identity during the DC Rebirth era, Kate told him she had worked it out years earlier.
The pair generally cooperate in the field, though their disagreements have sometimes become physical. In Batwoman #9, written by Greg Rucka with art by Leandro Fernández, Bruce challenges Kate over a gun she has been carrying.
Batman’s rule and the shooting
Batman’s main DC Comics portrayal avoids killing and using guns, and he expects his allies to respect those limits. A preview shows him troubled by Kate’s firearm and the apparent possibility that she used it to kill.
The three people fatally shot in issue #3 were killed by Beth, Kate’s sister, while wearing the Batwoman costume. Kate therefore did not break Batman’s no-kill rule in that incident. In the preview, she gives Bruce the gun after emptying its ammunition; he asks, “Why?”
The gun remains unexplained
Kate previously objected when Huntress suggested killing members of the GCPD TUCOs. Huntress, unaware that Beth had been dressed as Batwoman during the earlier killings, then asked Kate why she carried a gun. Kate replied that it was “not for show.”
The account expects Kate to explain the weapon to Bruce, but her reason is not yet clear. Bruce may still disapprove, setting up another verbal clash between the cousins.
Other armed Bat-Family members
Jason Todd, known as Red Hood, is another Bat-Family member who uses guns and has been willing to kill criminals. Since reconciling with Batman, he has mostly avoided killing and uses rubber bullets, though he sometimes kills particularly detestable adversaries.
Kate, by contrast, is not willing to cross that line. How long she will keep carrying a gun remains unclear.
Key points
- Batman confronts Kate Kane about the gun she carries in a preview of Batwoman #9.
- Beth, not Kate, shot three people while wearing the Batwoman costume in issue #3.
- Kate says she does not kill, but has not explained why she carries the firearm.
- Red Hood uses guns and rubber bullets, and sometimes kills criminals.

