Could Mauricio Pochettino's tactics help the Argentine solve Manchester United's problems?

A long-running United link

Pochettino’s name first emerged as a possible United manager in May 2016, after the club dismissed Louis van Gaal. Since Sir Alex Ferguson left in 2013, the club has moved between coaches with established playing philosophies and former Ferguson-era players.

Pochettino has spoken warmly about Ferguson. In a 2023 Sky Sports interview, while managing Chelsea, he said Ferguson had been an inspiration and reference when he began his managerial career.

Carrick’s attacking approach

Carrick’s United finished last season with a strong run of results, using attacks built around transitions. The approach suited direct forwards and offered protection to the defenders. When United took the lead, opponents often advanced and left more room to exploit. Carrick’s plan was to draw pressure, escape it and send the ball forward quickly, but opponents later worked out how to challenge the team.

Pochettino’s midfield ideas

Pochettino’s recent work with the United States showcased a flexible midfield and combinations in tight spaces. Players gathered centrally to draw opponents in, then looked for early passes behind the defence.

The movement could unsettle teams defending zones rather than marking individuals. Folarin Balogun’s pace helped him turn through-balls into chances, while Christian Pulisic and left-back Robinson exchanged positions to balance the attack.

Similarities and questions

The blend of close passing, a fluid midfield and direct forward balls has some resemblance to the direction Carrick was pursuing. Pochettino described his philosophy in 2014 as offering “a freer style with a good organisation.” Carrick’s early 4-2-4 press was effective, with four players staying high to help win possession and attack quickly. But when opponents adapted, United struggled to respond, underscoring the need for tactical flexibility as well as an attacking identity.