Who Could Lead a 2026 Recasting of Sabrina the Teenage Witch? 9 Main Roles Reimagined

A New Sabrina Takes Shape

Melissa Joan Hart played Sabrina in the 1996 sitcom, which became a major success and ran for seven seasons. A revival that returned to the original comedy’s lighter tone could take a different casting approach.

Ruby Stokes is proposed for the lead role. Her work since 2010 has included the film Una, stage performances, period dramas and dark comedies, giving her a range of experience for the mischievous young witch.

The Spellman Aunts

Gillian Jacobs is suggested as Hilda Spellman, Sabrina’s fun-loving aunt. Hilda often acts on impulse and joins Sabrina’s plans, sometimes getting into trouble with Zelda. Ayo Edebiri is proposed for Zelda, the more level-headed sister and voice of reason. Her role as Sydney in The Bear, where she eventually becomes head chef and co-owner, is cited as a fitting background for the character.

Salem And Harvey

Bill Hader is recommended for Salem, the sarcastic wizard punished by being turned into a cat after trying to take over the world. His comedy work and voice-acting credits are offered as reasons he could suit the role.

Jack Martin is suggested for Harvey Winkle, Sabrina’s awkward and endearing love interest. Martin began landing screen credits around 2020 and took a central role in the 2026 comedy series Not Suitable For Work, which was cancelled after its first season.

The Revival’s Wider Context

The franchise has also included an animated spin-off and sequel, several feature films, and a 2018 revival that took a darker approach. The 1996 feature film starred Hart and Ryan Reynolds.

The story begins to introduce Libby Chessler but ends before giving casting suggestions for her or explaining the remaining roles. It therefore provides only part of the proposed nine-role lineup.