Best Live-Action Batman of All Time: How Screen Rant Readers Ranked the Dark Knight

Seven Batmen, Different Gotham Worlds

Batman’s film appearances date back to Columbia Pictures adaptations in 1943 and 1949, though the article distinguishes those from a modern-style movie. Adam West played Bruce Wayne in the 1966 film, which it identifies as the first proper Batman movie.

Screen Rant asked readers to rank seven film portrayals: West, Michael Keaton, Val Kilmer, George Clooney, Christian Bale, Ben Affleck and Robert Pattinson. Each actor’s version, the article notes, belongs to a different iteration of Gotham.

Clooney Finishes At The Bottom

George Clooney placed last. He appeared as Batman in Batman & Robin, a film associated in the article with the franchise’s collapse and a shift toward exaggerated camp humor.

The article argues that the movie’s script and tone, rather than Clooney’s acting ability, shaped the poor reception. It says his humorous apologies over the years have helped audiences view him more warmly.

Kilmer’s Restrained Take Places Sixth

Val Kilmer ranked above Clooney. His film, Batman Forever, adopted a lighter, more family-friendly approach than the earlier Burton and Keaton movies and earned $336.6 million worldwide against a $100 million budget.

The article describes Kilmer’s performance as restrained and psychologically introspective, but says it did not match what audiences and critics expected after Keaton. It also notes renewed appreciation for Kilmer’s portrayal following his death last year.

West Comes In Fifth

Adam West placed fifth, despite being remembered as an iconic Batman. His earnest performance played against the 1960s series’ camp, with the article praising the seriousness he brought to absurd situations.

West’s version remained a joy to watch decades later, the article says, but its Gotham and tone differ from what modern viewers expect. It suggests the character’s evolution since 1966 may help explain the ranking.

Affleck Takes Fourth Place

Ben Affleck ranked fourth, despite the vocal support he has often received. The article lists his appearances in Batman V Superman (2016), Justice League (2017) and Zack Snyder’s Justice League (2021).