Skip to content
SurenoGet Sureno Browser
← Sureno News

Liverpool, Leny Yoro and the Premier League red card: was the decision correct?

The early sending-off

Ronald Araujo sent a long pass forward for Isak to chase. Yoro brought him down, and Barrott awarded a foul before showing the defender a red card. The dismissal came after eight minutes, making it Manchester United’s earliest red card in the Premier League. It was a pivotal moment in Mauricio Pochettino’s first game as the club’s boss.

Assessing the goal chance

For a red card denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity, officials consider four factors. Isak was running towards goal in a central position, and no covering defender was present, satisfying three of them.

Isak’s heavy touch sent the ball a few yards ahead. Barrott and VAR official John Brooks had to judge whether Isak would reach it before goalkeeper Senne Lammens, and whether that would leave him with a good scoring chance. The decision was described as borderline, meaning VAR would not normally step in unless there was a clear and obvious error.

Different views on the call

Former Liverpool and England midfielder Danny Murphy said there was “no doubt” about the red card. On Sky Sports, Neville said Yoro needed to cover but reacted late and showed poor anticipation.

A previous appeal by Brighton succeeded because there was clear doubt that Isidor would control the ball before it reached goalkeeper Bart Verbruggen. In another case, Ipswich’s Issa Diop avoided a VAR red card against Nottingham Forest, despite Forest boss Oliver Glasner insisting it was a clear goalscoring opportunity.

Appeal remains an option

Manchester United could appeal Yoro’s dismissal, and the report said there was little to lose by doing so. The contrasting cases underline how officials can reach different conclusions about whether a player had an obvious chance to score.

Such decisions are subjective, and agreement is often hard to find. The key question in Yoro’s case is whether Isak would have reached the ball before Lammens and had a strong chance to score.

Key points

  • Yoro’s eighth-minute dismissal was Manchester United’s earliest red card in the Premier League.
  • Isak’s heavy touch made it harder to judge whether he would reach the ball before Lammens.
  • Danny Murphy supported the red card, while other comparable cases show how subjective the assessment can be.
  • Manchester United could appeal the decision.
Read the original on BBC Sport ↗

More news

Loading stories…