After Suno tracks surfaced, Binding of Isaac developer removes AI music from Repentance Plus amid backlash

Players trace music to Suno
Reddit user ShweetsStuff identified songs in a Grand Theft Auto-themed part of the game. Several audio files contained Suno metadata, which linked them to tracks on the service’s website.
The discovery led to a wave of negative reviews on Steam. The music was part of the latest version of The Binding of Isaac: Repentance Plus.
McMillen says he was unaware
Creator Edmund McMillen apologized on X and said he had not known that generative AI music was included in the in-game parody. He has previously criticized AI in game development. In a 2024 TikTok, McMillen described AI game content as “uninspired and bland.” Some users on X appeared to give him the benefit of the doubt after his response.
Studio removes generated tracks
Nicalis, Inc., the studio behind Repentance Plus, said on X that it had updated the game and removed the generated music files. The update came within hours of the discovery.
Key points
- Reddit user ShweetsStuff found Suno metadata in music files used in a game segment.
- Edmund McMillen apologized and said he had not known the parody used AI-generated music.
- Nicalis removed the generated tracks in an update announced on X.
- Steam reviews had not rebounded, and the game remained rated “overwhelmingly negative.”

