Backpacker compromise another example of Albanese government folding its cards, view from the hill

Backpacker rules revised
Tony Burke announced an overhaul of working-holiday rules on Tuesday, stepping back from details of the original plan. He says the revised approach will benefit regional areas without affecting overseas net migration.
The updated model slows the number of first-year backpackers but increases the number who can stay for a third year. It also increases the overall hours worked in regional areas, while changing the original ballot into an “invitation.” The opposition calls the change a con. Whether it delivers on labour needs and proves politically effective remains to be seen.
A pattern of policy changes
Governments may describe such moves as removing political irritants, making a backflip or changing position. In each case, a policy is adjusted or abandoned after opposition from stakeholders or the wider community; Senate difficulties and consultation can also play a part.
Recent examples include plans to sell surplus defence properties and a proposed $5,000 cap on allied health support for veterans. Following campaigns against them, Victoria Barracks in Sydney and some other high-profile properties were removed from the sale list, while the government withdrew the veterans’ cap proposal.
The government also delayed a ban on using credit cards to pay tax bills, covering the cost until mid next year while consultations continue. In October, it dropped a plan to split disaster recovery funding equally with the states.
Health rebate decision ahead
The unresolved question is a budget proposal to reduce the extra private health insurance rebate for older Australians. The Greens say they will support it only if pensioners are excluded.
The proposed measure would save $3 billion over the budget period. Excluding pensioners would reduce that saving by $1.6 billion, while failing to reach agreement with the Greens could put the full saving at risk.
The government must decide whether to resist the Greens or accept a compromise and secure a smaller saving. Either course carries a budget cost.
Key points
- The revised working-holiday rules increase regional work hours and the number eligible for a third year.
- Burke says the changes will not affect overseas net migration.
- The government has modified or withdrawn several contested measures after public campaigns.
- The Greens want pensioners excluded from the proposed rebate cut before supporting it.

