6 Best Books of 2025, Ranked: Five Standouts and a Missing Sixth

A list built from memorable pages
The writer says each especially affecting book gets a folded page corner. At the end of 2025, those marked pages—not bestseller lists—became the basis for choosing favorites. The introduction promises six varied books, including stories of a vampire in Montana, a director caught in Nazi Germany, sisters facing a family curse and an angel in World War I. The text that follows, however, identifies only five titles or descriptions.
History, family and forgiveness
In Stephen Graham Jones’s The Buffalo Hunter Hunter, professor Etsy Beck discovers a journal by her ancestor, pastor Arthur Beck, in Miles City, Montana. It recounts Good Stab’s story of becoming a vampire and seeking revenge, against the history of the 1870 Marias Massacre.
Jonas Hassen Khemiri’s The Sisters follows Ina, Evelyn and Anastasia Mikkola across more than 30 years, while Jonas repeatedly crosses their paths. Another selection, whose title is not given, follows an unnamed woman who joins a religious community in New South Wales; a mouse plague, returned remains and an old school acquaintance disrupt her quiet life.
Art under pressure, unfinished list
Daniel Kehlmann’s The Director portrays G.W. Pabst’s gradual acceptance of work for the Nazis after the director becomes stranded in Austria during the war. The text also notes Ross Benjamin’s English translation and frames the story around artistic compromise.
The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny begins with grandparents in India hoping Sonia, an art student in Vermont, and Sunny, a journalist in New York, will become a couple. The account stops while describing their years of relationships, family pressure and loneliness, and supplies neither a completed description nor a sixth selection.
Key points
- The list says it contains six books, but only five selections are identifiable in the text.
- The Buffalo Hunter Hunter connects a vampire story with the 1870 Marias Massacre.
- The Director examines G.W. Pabst’s compromises under Nazi rule.
- The final description ends unfinished, leaving the ranking incomplete.

