Rings of Power Kills Its Samwise Gamgee Version in a Stark Season 3 Twist

A familiar trio takes shape
Before season 3 premiered, promotional material emphasized Galadriel, Arondir and Marnûkh. Showrunner Patrick McKay described them as resembling Frodo, Sam and Gollum. Their journey also includes a departure from Rivendell as a fellowship and an escape on Eagles.
Galadriel trusts Marnûkh, while Arondir distrusts him. Their roles initially appear to follow the familiar pattern of a determined hero, loyal companion and suspect guide.
A role reversal ends in tragedy
In the final moments of episode 4, Theo, who has become a Nazgnagôl, stabs and kills Arondir. The death makes the Samwise comparison especially striking, since Sam survives the events of The Lord of the Rings and helps protect Frodo.
The season also reverses the original dynamic: Galadriel is right to trust her seemingly villainous guide, while Arondir must accept that his suspicion was misplaced. The different outcome turns the familiar parallel into a tragic twist.
Earlier Hobbit echoes remain
The series previously drew a Frodo-and-Sam connection through Harfoots Nori, played by Markella Kavenagh, and Poppy, played by Megan Richards. In the show’s story, they are Hobbit ancestors and among the first to greet Gandalf in Middle-earth.
Key points
- Season 3 links Galadriel, Arondir and Marnûkh to Frodo, Sam and Gollum.
- Theo kills Arondir in episode 4 after becoming a Nazgnagôl.
- Galadriel’s trust in Marnûkh proves justified, reversing the familiar story dynamic.
- Nori and Poppy have been absent since leaving Gandalf at the end of season 2.

