Blue Wave Lifted Democrats, Yet Some Progressives Rose Less High

A debate renewed by results
Democrats have argued for nearly a decade over whether the party should move left or toward the center. This month’s midterm results offered evidence for both sides, setting up the debate to continue into the next presidential primary.
Some progressive candidates fell short by enough to keep the longstanding electability argument in play. Many of the Democratic Party’s weakest performances relative to the national environment and local characteristics came in races where progressives had won contested summer nominations.
Progressive candidates also won
The results were not uniformly poor for progressives. In congressional contests in Montana, Ohio and Pennsylvania, populist candidates with blue-collar backgrounds, including firefighters and union leaders, won in districts that had backed President Trump in the last election.
Progressives, like Democrats across ideological groups, also did exceptionally well in districts with large Hispanic populations. Those gains included battleground areas in California and Colorado.
How the shift was measured
The shift toward Democrats was calculated by comparing 2026 Senate results with the 2024 presidential results. The comparison provides context for how candidates performed against the broader political environment.
Key points
- Midterm results are likely to extend Democrats’ debate over moving left or toward the center.
- Some progressive nominees underperformed, keeping electability questions alive.
- Populists with blue-collar backgrounds won congressional races in Trump-voting districts in Montana, Ohio and Pennsylvania.
- Progressives did well in districts with large Hispanic populations, including battlegrounds in California and Colorado.

