NSW proposed laws to allow coalmine increase in production pose serious corruption risk, barrister warns

Bill follows court ruling
The government says the measure is needed to prevent 400 jobs at the mine from being lost before Christmas. Debate is expected in the lower house on Tuesday, with the upper house to consider it later in the week.
Concerns over ministerial powers
Watson, the Greens and some crossbench members have objected to Clause 17, which they say would let the resources minister override other state laws for the mine. Such provisions are known as Henry VIII clauses, a reference to the king’s use of royal proclamations.
In his analysis, Watson said the clause would place wide lawmaking powers in the hands of one minister for one coal company. He said the risk was heightened because the bill was designed for a single private firm, while making clear he did not accuse the current minister of bad faith.
Watson said corruption could involve undue influence or decisions made outside the public interest, not only payments. The article also attributes to a woman a warning that the provision could affect laws on noise, dust and worker safety, but does not identify her.
Parties take opposing views
Greens climate spokesperson Sue Higginson called the clause the broadest Henry VIII provision she had seen in the current parliament. The Greens will seek to remove it or restrict its reach, she said, while noting such provisions can be narrowly used to carry out parliament’s decisions.
One Nation NSW leader and Cessnock candidate Mike Newman called the bill a “Band-Aid on a bullet-wound,” while arguing that projects supported by most of the community should not be delayed by environmental legal challenges. Independent MP Alex Greenwich, who plans to oppose the bill, described the provision as dangerously broad and unprecedented.
Key points
- The bill would increase production at Mount Pleasant coalmine after a High Court ruling invalidated expansion approval.
- The government says the legislation is needed to protect 400 jobs before Christmas.
- Geoffrey Watson and critics warn Clause 17 gives the resources minister unusually broad authority over state laws.
- The lower house is expected to debate the bill Tuesday, followed by the upper house later in the week.

