York lawsuit challenges state social media warning label law in federal court

NetChoice challenges the law
NetChoice filed its lawsuit against New York in federal court on Friday. The internet trade group represents more than 30 members, including Google, YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat and TikTok.
The group argues that the state is compelling its members to display a message it prefers, violating First Amendment protections. NetChoice says the law is designed to pressure social media users into seeing the notices.
Warnings target platform features
The law applies to platforms using infinite scrolling, autoplay or algorithmic feeds. It requires them to display state-approved warnings about potential harms to younger users. The notice is to include a caution from the U.S. Surgeon General that excessive social media use may be associated with significant mental health harms for young users. The statement draws on a 2023 advisory issued by then-Surgeon General Vivek Murthy.
Dispute echoes other cases
NetChoice says the New York measure resembles a Colorado law that a federal judge preliminarily blocked a year ago on First Amendment grounds. The group has also filed a similar lawsuit against California.
Key points
- NetChoice sued New York in federal court over the state's social media warning label law.
- The law covers platforms using infinite scrolling, autoplay or algorithmic feeds.
- The required warning cites potential mental health harms for younger users.
- NetChoice argues the law violates First Amendment protections.

