German classrooms are fighting AI’s great dumbing down as teachers debate restrictions

AI moves into schoolwork
Jakob, a 15-year-old at a German gymnasium, says he has used AI tools with classmates for two and a half years. He used ChatGPT to review French topics before a test and has also turned to AI for homework when stuck.
These tools can provide answers or solutions across subjects including mathematics, German, English, chemistry and physics. Researchers call the transfer of thinking to an outside tool “cognitive outsourcing,” a process that can extend further with a large language model than with a calculator or notepad.
Teachers see a growing dependence
German teacher Franziska Müller says some students struggle to think independently. In class, she has seen students consult AI on phones or tablets and read out prepared answers when called on.
Müller also believes students understand texts less well because they read less and use AI to summarize material. Jakob, however, says students who earn good grades are generally not letting AI do all their homework.
Research raises concerns
The OECD’s Andreas Schleicher wrote that students who report using AI chatbots score lower in science on average than students who do not. The reported uses included summarizing assigned reading, researching a topic and drafting written work.
Germany’s 15-year-olds achieved their lowest PISA scores in the study’s 25-year history. Schleicher said the links are complex and depend on how generative AI is used, while stressing that learning requires active mental effort.
Rules remain contested
The Brookings Institution has argued that the risks of AI in education outweigh its benefits. Its research describes possible losses in foundational skills, critical thinking, memory, perseverance and independent judgment as students rely on AI for intellectual work.
New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani banned AI use in public schools through eighth grade for the 2026 and 2027 school years. German teacher Julian Hinn questioned whether bans can work, saying students can still use apps on their phones and at home.
Key points
- Jakob says students at his gymnasium have used AI tools for two and a half years.
- A teacher says some students read AI-prepared answers aloud in class.
- The OECD reported lower average science scores among students who said they used AI chatbots.
- Germany’s 15-year-olds recorded their lowest PISA scores in the study’s 25-year history.

