Why These 5 Biggest Criminal Minds Actor Exits Left a Mark on TVLine’s Crime Drama History

Patinkin rejected the series’ content
Lola Glaudini’s Elle Greenway was the first cast member to leave, departing during Season 2. The first exit that drew major shock was Mandy Patinkin’s, who chose not to return for Season 3 after playing veteran BAU member Jason Gideon.
The departure was initially attributed to creative differences. In a 2012 interview with New York Magazine, Patinkin said he had misunderstood what the show would be and described its repeated depictions of violence against women as damaging to his well-being.
Gideon remained part of the show’s history through references and flashbacks. The character was killed in Season 10, ruling out further appearances.
Gibson was dismissed in 2016
Thomas Gibson played BAU Unit Chief Aaron Hotchner for 12 seasons before CBS fired him in 2016. The dismissal followed an altercation with writer and producer Virgil Williams over a line change; Gibson allegedly kicked Williams.
The report also cited earlier incidents: Gibson allegedly shoved an assistant director in 2010 and was required to take anger management classes. In 2013, he was charged with alcohol-related reckless driving, and staff members had to drive him to and from work.
The series explained Hotchner’s absence by having him enter Witness Protection with his son Jack, after renewed threats from Mr. Scratch. After his firing, Gibson appeared in the film Axis and starred in Shadow Wolves; more recently, he has worked in theater.
Cook’s exit prompted backlash
A.J. Cook, who played Jennifer “JJ” Jareau, was let go before Season 6 in 2010. Her character had started as the BAU’s media liaison and later became an agent.
The decision was initially presented as financially motivated, but Cook was replaced by Rachel Nichols. Fans objected, with some saying the move suggested sexism. Cook told TV Guide Magazine that the firing felt like an unexpected breakup.
Co-star Paget Brewster, who was also fired around that period, discussed the decision in an interview with A.V. Club. Cook’s departure surprised the actor herself.
Key points
- Criminal Minds: Evolution was canceled after the series reached 20 seasons.
- Mandy Patinkin chose not to return for Season 3 and later criticized the show’s content.
- Thomas Gibson was fired in 2016 after an altercation with producer Virgil Williams.
- A.J. Cook was dismissed before Season 6 in 2010, prompting fan backlash.

