After Victorian Psycho, 10 horror movies to watch featuring complex killer women

A tradition of female killers
Horror has featured women as killers across generations, including Asa in Mario Bava’s Black Sunday, Pearl in Ti West’s X trilogy and Annie Wilkes in Misery, which is streaming on Tubi. Other examples include Pamela Voorhees in Friday the 13th, Julia in Hellraiser and Tiffany Valentine in the Child’s Play franchise.
In Victorian Psycho, Maika Monroe plays governess Winifred Notty, whose silliness sits alongside an obsession with death. ScreenRant critic Alex Harrison said Monroe uses “creepy grins and ecstatic contortions” to make the character frightening.
Revenge and bodily autonomy
Jen and Sylvia Soska’s American Mary follows medical student Mary Mason, played by Katharine Isabelle of Ginger Snaps. Facing financial ruin, Mary seeks quick money in the body-modification community. After an assault, she kidnaps her former teacher and abuser to perform extreme, illegal surgery, then leaves her residency to work in body modification full-time.
The film explores accountability, retribution and bodily autonomy. Its themes resonated with the Me Too movement, which Tarana Burke began in 2006 and which saw a resurgence in the mid-2010s as public figures including Alyssa Milano shared their experiences. The film also leans heavily on practical effects.
Horror rooted in coercion
In Christopher Wesley Moore’s Children of Sin, teenagers are sent by their religious zealot parents to a gay conversion camp. The camp’s owner, Mary Esther, played by Jo-Ann Robinson, believes the young people have been condemned and must seek forgiveness.
The film draws on the real-life horror of conversion camps and builds a more repulsive story from that premise. Robinson’s performance recalls Wendy Robie’s unhinged role in Wes Craven’s The People Under the Stairs, embracing the character’s disgust and self-loathing.
Twists and painful isolation
Jonathan Levine’s All the Boys Love Mandy Lane begins like an exploitative, grimy example of the era’s “torture porn,” then shifts into something unexpected. Amber Heard, in one of her earliest roles, anchors the film as Mandy Lane. The story’s major twist is best left undisclosed.
In Lucky McKee’s May, Angela Bettis plays an outsider carrying the effects of a painful childhood and years of bullying into adulthood. May forms connections with Polly, played by Anna Faris, and Adam, played by Jeremy Sisto. After she is spurned, her life spirals off course.
Key points
- Victorian Psycho features Maika Monroe as governess Winifred Notty, a character with an obsession with death.
- American Mary links body modification, revenge and bodily autonomy through medical student Mary Mason.
- Children of Sin centers on teenagers sent to a gay conversion camp by their parents.
- All the Boys Love Mandy Lane shifts from a grim horror setup into an unexpected story.

