A Sleep Study Changes Matt Hagen: Clayface’s Most Emotionally Complex Transformation Scene Explained by Director James Watkins

A scene built on uncertainty
In an interview with ScreenRant’s Andy Behbakht, Watkins discussed the scene in which Caitlyn, played by Naomi Ackie, observes Matt, played by Tom Rhys Harries, during his treatment. Matt is beginning to change, and Caitlyn grows concerned about what may be happening while he sleeps.
Watkins said the scene carries an uneasy, intimate tone. He described it as having qualities of a love scene, while also centering on a doctor watching her patient and a scientist observing her project.
Blurring science and attraction
The film leaves open how Caitlyn sees Matt: as a subject of scientific study, as a man, or both. Watkins said the story explores a transfer of roles and feelings between them, while leaving the source of any attraction unclear.
He said that uncertainty was intended to make viewers lean into the moment. The scene raises questions about whether their closeness comes from attraction, or from their doctor-patient relationship and the possibility that Matt has cured her.
Practical work shaped the effect
Watkins said the crew filmed the scene in different arrangements, sometimes with Ackie in the chair and no one in the bed, and at other times with the actors placed in the bed or chair separately. They also filmed moments with both performers positioned in the bed, including shots where Harries was outside the camera’s view.
The actors repeated and mirrored each other’s movements across takes, Watkins said. Editor Jon Harris could then blend the performances using a simple overlay, with visual effects added at points where skin or an eye merged.
A hypnotic, uneasy mood
Watkins said the practical approach helped create fluidity in the scene, alongside music discussed with composer Volker Bertelmann. He wanted the audience to feel drawn in without being directed toward a particular response.
The result, he said, has a voyeuristic unease: viewers may wonder whether they should watch or enjoy what they are seeing. Watkins also said he admires Alfred Hitchcock and aspires to that kind of cinematic interplay.
Key points
- Watkins frames Matt and Caitlyn’s scene as intimate, unsettling and deliberately ambiguous.
- The film leaves uncertain whether Caitlyn’s interest is scientific, personal or both.
- Actors mirrored each other’s movements to support practical blending in the edit.
- Visual effects were used where skin or an eye had to merge.

